Question

How to find the allowed range of k in a sector area problem

Original question: (b) For the general case in which angle BAC=θBAC = \theta radians, where 0<θ<12π0<\theta<\frac{1}{2}\pi, it is given that θsinθ>1\frac{\theta}{\sin\theta}>1.

Find the set of possible values of kk.

0<\theta<90^\circ

[3]

Expert Verified Solution

thumb_up100%(1 rated)

Key concept: This problem mixes sector area and a small triangle inside the sector. The useful move is to write both areas in terms of aa, kk, and θ\theta, then compare them directly.

Step by step

Let the sector have radius aa and angle θ\theta, where

0<θ<π20<\theta<\frac{\pi}{2}

Since AD=AE=kaAD=AE=ka, triangle ADEADE has area

Area of ADE=12(ka)(ka)sinθ=12k2a2sinθ\text{Area of }\triangle ADE=\frac12(ka)(ka)\sin\theta=\frac12k^2a^2\sin\theta

The whole sector has area

12a2θ\frac12a^2\theta

The line DEDE divides the sector into two equal areas, so triangle ADEADE must be half the sector:

12k2a2sinθ=14a2θ\frac12k^2a^2\sin\theta=\frac14a^2\theta

Cancel a2a^2:

k2sinθ=θ2k^2\sin\theta=\frac\theta2

So

k2=θ2sinθk^2=\frac{\theta}{2\sin\theta}

We are told that

θsinθ>1\frac{\theta}{\sin\theta}>1

Hence

k2>12k>12k^2>\frac12 \quad\Rightarrow\quad k>\frac1{\sqrt2}

Also, because 0<θ<π20<\theta<\frac{\pi}{2}, we have sinθ<1\sin\theta<1 and therefore

k2=θ2sinθ<π/22=π4k^2=\frac{\theta}{2\sin\theta}<\frac{\pi/2}{2}=\frac\pi4

So

k<π2k<\frac{\sqrt\pi}{2}

Set of possible values of kk

12<k<π2\frac1{\sqrt2}<k<\frac{\sqrt\pi}{2}

Pitfall alert

Don't use the sector formula with the wrong region. The equal-area condition applies to the triangle ADEADE versus the remaining part of the sector, so the triangle must be exactly half the sector, not the whole thing. Another easy slip is dropping the square on kk when substituting the triangle area.

Try different conditions

If the sector angle were fixed to a specific value, then kk would be found directly from

k=θ2sinθk=\sqrt{\frac{\theta}{2\sin\theta}}

For angles closer to 0, θ/sinθ\theta/\sin\theta is close to 1, so kk approaches 1/21/\sqrt2. As θ\theta moves toward π/2\pi/2, the value of kk increases.

Further reading

sector area, triangle area, equal areas

FAQ

How do you find k in the equal-area sector problem?

Write the area of triangle ADE as 1/2 k^2 a^2 sin(theta) and set it equal to half the sector area, 1/4 a^2 theta. This gives k^2 = theta/(2 sin(theta)).

What is the possible range of k?

Using 0 < theta < pi/2 and theta/sin(theta) > 1, the possible values are 1/sqrt(2) < k < sqrt(pi)/2.

chat