Question
Finding an equivalent polar coordinate representation
Original question: The location of a point in the plane is given by polar coordinates . Which of the following gives another representation for this point in polar coordinates?
A B C D
Correct A Correct. In this case, another representation is given by . Add or subtract a multiple of to to get another representation of the point, . This does not change the location of the terminal ray for an angle in standard position, measuring counterclockwise from the polar (horizontal) axis. Consider to be the same distance from the origin as but in the opposite direction of the terminal ray of the angle. Therefore, another representation of the point is given by , where an odd multiple of is added or subtracted to .
Expert Verified Solution
Key concept: This question checks the two standard rules for polar coordinates: adding multiples of and switching the sign of .
Step by step
Key idea
A polar point can be represented in more than one way. The two main equivalence rules are:
Here the given point is
Because the radius is negative, we can rewrite the point with a positive radius by adding to the angle:
Now simplify the angle:
So the equivalent polar coordinate is
which is choice A.
Why this works
A negative radius means you move in the direction opposite the terminal ray of the angle. Flipping the sign of requires a half-turn, which is exactly radians. That is why the angle changes by when changes sign.
If you only add to the angle while keeping , the location is still the same point, but the answer choices ask for another representation, and the positive-radius form is the clearest match.
Check the choices
- A : correct, because it uses the same point with positive radius.
- B : incorrect, because changing the sign of without changing the angle changes the point.
- C : incorrect, because this is a different terminal ray.
- D : equivalent to the original point, but the intended standard equivalent form is still choice A.
So the correct answer is .
Pitfall alert
A frequent mistake is to think that changing from negative to positive does not affect the angle. In polar coordinates, a negative radius always points in the opposite direction, so the angle must shift by . Another error is adding and expecting that alone to change a negative-radius point into a positive-radius point. It does not. The sign change and the angle shift work together. Also watch the trigonometric quadrant: is in Quadrant IV, which matches the direction opposite .
Try different conditions
If the point were , then an equivalent representation would be , because switching the sign of requires adding to the angle. If the point were , you could subtract to rewrite it as , which is still the same location. These variants show that either the radius sign changes with a shift, or the angle changes by multiples of .
Further reading
polar coordinate equivalence, negative radius, terminal ray