Question
Modelling salt concentration with a mixing differential equation
Original question: 5. A tank at a chemical plant has a capacity of 250 litres. The tank initially contains 100 litres of pure water.
Salt water enters the tank at a rate of 3 litres every minute. Each litre of salt water entering the tank contains 1 gram of salt.
It is assumed that the salt water mixes instantly with the contents of the tank upon entry.
At the instant when the salt water begins to enter the tank, a valve is opened at the bottom of the tank and the solution in the tank flows out at a rate of 2 litres per minute.
Given that there are grams of salt in the tank after minutes,
(a) show that the situation can be modelled by the differential equation
(4)
Expert Verified Solution
Key takeaway: This mixing problem uses conservation of salt and volume change to build a first-order differential equation.
Key modelling principle
Let be the grams of salt in the tank after minutes.
The tank starts with 100 litres of water, and salt water enters at 3 litres per minute. Since the outflow is 2 litres per minute, the volume increases by 1 litre per minute.
So after minutes, the volume in the tank is
Salt entering and leaving
Salt enters with concentration 1 gram per litre, at 3 litres per minute. Therefore the rate of salt entering is
The salt leaving depends on the concentration in the tank. Since the tank is well mixed, the concentration is
The outflow rate is 2 litres per minute, so the salt leaving per minute is
Form the differential equation
Rate of change = rate in - rate out:
This is exactly the required model.
Why the volume matters
A mixing problem is not just about salt amount. The changing volume affects concentration, and concentration determines how much salt leaves each minute. If the volume were constant, the differential equation would be much simpler. Here, the rising volume is the reason the denominator is , not just 100.
Final answer
The model is
This equation expresses conservation of salt in the tank over time.
Pitfalls the pros know π A common mistake is to use the inflow rate 3 litres per minute as if it were the salt rate itself without checking the concentration. In this problem that happens to be correct only because each litre of incoming solution contains exactly 1 gram of salt. Another error is to forget that the tank volume changes over time. If you write the outflow concentration using a fixed 100 litres, the model becomes wrong immediately. The denominator must match the actual volume at time .
What if the problem changes? If the inflow were still 3 litres per minute but each litre contained 2 grams of salt, then the input term would be 6 instead of 3, giving . If the outflow rate changed to 4 litres per minute, the volume would increase by only 1 litre per minute net, so the same volume formula would remain, but the leaving term would become . The modelling structure stays the same; only the coefficients change.
Tags: mixing model, concentration function, first-order differential equation
FAQ
Why is the tank volume written as 100 plus t litres?
The tank starts with 100 litres. It gains 3 litres per minute and loses 2 litres per minute, so the net increase is 1 litre per minute. After t minutes, the volume is 100+t litres.
How is the rate of salt leaving the tank calculated?
Because the mixture is uniform, the concentration is S/(100+t) grams per litre. Multiplying by the outflow rate of 2 litres per minute gives the leaving rate 2S/(100+t).